Judge Andrew Napolitano says that Hillary Clinton is “laughing” at the FBI when she claims that agency is conducting a “security review” instead of an investigation.
During an interview with Bill Hemmer on Fox News’s “America’s News Room” on Friday, Napolitano argued that in fact Clinton does know that “she’s the target of the criminal investigation.”
“What she’s done is for the umpteenth time in public sent a dog whistle to the FBI, a signal to the FBI,” Napolitano said. “She forgot they were watching. She knows it is a criminal investigation, she knows she’s the target of the criminal investigation, she knows the government has an extraordinary amount of resources investigating her, and she is laughing at them. Not a good thing to do.”
For nearly two decades, we’ve been told that this is the Golden Age of Television: the smartest, deepest storytelling, the most nuanced and morally complex characters, are found here. Perhaps it’s time for a reconsideration.
Thursday night, on ABC’s “Scandal,” Olivia Pope, the protagonist — long established in the show’s vernacular as a “white hat,” or good guy — beat a wheelchair-bound stroke victim to death by pulping his face with an aluminum chair.
It was a lengthy scene, and even for a Shonda Rhimes soap that bills itself weekly on “OMG twists” — gruesome scenes of torture and dismemberment, politically expedient murders and illegitimate war, rape, kidnapping, blackmail, and one interminable scene where an imprisoned terrorist chewed through her own wrist to escape — this one was morally and artistically bankrupt.
“Scandal” protagonist Olivia Pope beats a man to death in a scene from the ABC show.Photo: ABC
“One of the worst things I’ve ever seen on television,” said the Onion’s AV Club.
“Making Liv an outright murderer? Come on,” wrote a commenter on Vulture. “Although knowing this show, in about three episodes it will be as if this never happened.”
Today, the Golden Age is in the throes of an arms race, with show runners attempting to out-shock their audiences week-to-week, churning out melodrama without consequence.
Last week, on HBO’s “Girls,” Lena Dunham’s Hannah, teaching at a junior high school, responded to her principal’s warnings about unprofessional behavior by exposing her vagina — to him and the audience. Outlandishly, it saved her job.
On “Mr. Robot,” a highly-acclaimed USA program, one character strangles another to death during a rooftop tryst, for no discernable reason. His pregnant wife then stabs herself in the uterus, with a fondue fork, to induce labor when the cops arrive.
The sophisticated spy thriller “The Americans” features a plotline about a grown man seducing a 15-year-old girl. Carrie Mathison, anti-heroine of “Homeland,” fell in love with a terrorist, had his baby, then tried to kill the infant. She kept custody and continued, of course, to work with the US government.
Robin Wright in “House of Cards.”Photo: Netflix
On the most recent season of “House of Cards,” First Lady Claire Underwood — who we’re meant to find more sympathetic than her amoral, homicidal husband Frank — kills her mother, via lethal injection, during an election cycle for voter sympathy.
There is no camp here; the scene is played straight, somber, all amber hues and meaningful looks. We are meant to infer guilt and regret, as if that makes everything OK.
In a post-“Sopranos” landscape, moral transgression automatically signifies high art. Infanticide, incest, pedophilia, matricide, torture, rape, castration, cannibalism, mass murder — all are now commonly employed tropes meant to signify quality.
“It’s almost hard to fathom how far we’ve come in such a short time,” says Brett Martin, author of “Difficult Men: Behind the Scenes of a Creative Revolution.” Martin agrees that “The Sopranos,” which premiered on HBO in 1999, is responsible for the programming we see today. Before Tony Soprano, American TV audiences had never been so consistently exposed to a charming psychopath, one who so nimbly evoked fear, revulsion, sympathy, affection, horror.
“The degree to which ‘The Sopranos’ and its kind were a shock is incredible,” Martin says. “We’re still in the grips of that.”
“The Sopranos” spawned a hunger for antiheroes: “The Shield,” “Damages,” “Dexter,” “Rescue Me,” “Mad Men,” “Breaking Bad,” “Sons of Anarchy,” “The Walking Dead,” “Homeland,” “House of Cards,” “The Americans,” “Girls,” “unREAL,” “Mr. Robot,” and, of course, “Game of Thrones” — these are just some of its direct descendants.
Shooting your own mom is all right on “Sons of Anarchy.”Photo: FX
Each of these shows are peopled with characters that range from sinister to sociopathic. Anyone remotely sympathetic in these worlds is always the stooge, the too-trusting idiot who elicits contempt from the audience.
In November, The Atlantic ran a bracket “to find the most terrible person on television.” There were 32 contestants, ranging from cannibalistic serial killer Hannibal Lecter to the 20-something narcissists of HBO’s “Girls.”
Winner of that bracket, by the way: “Game of Thrones’” Ramsay Bolton, who, as one editor wrote, “has spent the majority of his screen time torturing people, feeding women to dogs, and sexually assaulting the teenaged Sansa Stark on the night of their (forced) marriage. He does almost all of this with an impish grin on his face.”
Until last season, “Game of Thrones,” with its literary pedigree and HBO halo, was unassailable: there was no level of degeneracy or debasement the audience wouldn’t stomach. This was the highest art premium cable had to offer.
Then came two scenes that were not in the books: First, the rape of Sansa Stark, which caused thousands of fans, including a member of Congress, to erupt on Twitter.
“OK, I’m done with ‘Game of Thrones,’ ” tweeted Sen. Claire McCaskill. “Gratuitous rape scene disgusting and unacceptable.”
Then came the burning of a child, alive at the stake, by her own father.
“A little girl burned alive? Seriously? I honestly didn’t think they’d go there,” tweeted another viewer.
“Game of Thrones: the show that made dragons, rape, and child prostitution fashionable,” wrote another. “You go, HBO.”
‘At a certain point, as always happens in Hollywood or culture in general, a set of superficial things come to stand in for quality: sex, violence, moral complication.’
- Brett Martin, author of ‘Difficult Men: Behind the Scenes of a Creative Revolution’
Last December, “GoT” director Jeremy Podeswa, who directed the rape scene, said the show’s creators “were responsive to the discussion, and there were a couple of things changed as a result.”
Podeswa himself said that he found value in the audience challenging the “use of violence as a narrative tool . . . and the questionable nature of that.”
Other show runners are questioning their own motivations. Joe Weisberg, creator of FX’s critically-acclaimed “The Americans,” recently said he and the show’s writers grapple with what’s true to the characters.
“It may be that our sense of bad is changing,” he told critic Alan Sepinwall. “When they poisoned that kid, we couldn’t believe we were having those guys do that. We have become somewhat inured ourselves, so maybe we have to up the ante for us to feel it ourselves. We have to have them kill and old lady with her own pills to make it feel so bad.”
Perhaps we shouldn’t be surprised that it takes so much to shock us now. Like any art form, television is as much a reflection of the culture as a mover.
Look at the election cycle: Donald Trump, the GOP front-runner, is the first presidential nominee to come out of reality TV. Boasting about his penis size — totally in character.
The revival of the wholesome 1970s game show “Family Feud,” hosted by Steve Harvey, has recently been criticized for sexually explicit Q&As.
In two clips posted last September, Harvey asked a contestant to recall “the last thing you stuck your finger in.”
“My wife.”
“My favorite answer of all time,” Harvey said.
“Name the first part of a woman you touch to get her in the mood,” Harvey asked another panel.
“Um, that would be the lower part of the vagina,” said one contestant, whom Harvey high-fived.
According to a survey released last week by Ipsos Public Affairs, 78% of Americans said they often heard people cursing in public, up 35% from ten years ago. It underscores the popularity of Donald Trump, who mouthed the word “f—ing” at a rally in New Hampshire and called Ted Cruz a “p—y.”
“It marks a huge shift in how we view politicians,” Ipsos senior research manager Kaitlyn McAuliffe said, “and what can work in a presidential campaign.”
Daniel Fienberg, television critic for the Hollywood Reporter, sees the connective tissue between pop culture and the presidential election cycle.
“I think it’s clear that we look at society and clearly don’t think it’s all white hats,” he says. “Presidential candidates used to be people you could look up to. Guess what? There are more antiheroes there, too.”
With few exceptions, there are scant, meaningful explorations of good and evil, action and consequence, to be found in our so-called Golden Age.
It’s worth remembering that David Chase, who created Tony Soprano, very artfully walked his audience up through the final season, in which he unmasked his antihero as an irredeemable psychopath. In doing so, he forced his audience to confront why we continued to overlook and excuse Tony’s most reprehensible actions, and what that says about our own susceptibilities to power, charm, wealth and fame.
Bryan Cranston and Aaron Paul in “Breaking Bad”
“Breaking Bad” showrunner Vince Gilligan did a similar thing, making clear that his was a moral universe, and Walter White, no matter his or the audience’s justifications, had to be punished. He also admitted that he, too, once felt affection for his protagonist, but could no longer deny the evil Walter had done.
“I’ve lost sympathy for Walter White, personally,” he said in 2013, right before the final season aired. “My perceptions have changed . . . I didn’t think that was going to happen.”
Even then, Gilligan didn’t understand the unquenchable thirst for antiheroes. “Our viewing tastes are cyclical,” he told Vulture. “Five years from now, [people] might be asking, ‘You remember when everybody used to like antiheroes? People like the guy in the white hat again. How did that happen? What’s changed in America?’”
If the recent reactions to “GoT’ and “Scandal” are an indication, there may be a backlash to bad behavior — or at least bad storytelling.
“At a certain point, as always happens in Hollywood or culture in general, a set of superficial things come to stand in for quality: sex, violence, moral complication,” says Martin. “When done well, it’s the highest form of art. If it’s done poorly, and if that’s all you’ve got — the idea that quality is tied to immorality — you enter the realm of the absurd.”
By Rev. Austin MilesGREENSBORO, NC 4/9/16—Yesterday, Friday, rocker Bruce Springsteen suddenly cancelled his scheduled performance at the Greensboro Coliseum which was set for tomorrow, Sunday. There was no advance notice, nor a valid reason to cancel. Fifteen thousand tickets had been sold in advance, purchased by people who had long ago made preparations to set aside this weekend to hear “the boss.”
And why the cancellation? Bruce Springsteen says he is punishing North Carolina for vetoing a law that prevents sexual misfits from having unlimited access to toilets, bathrooms, lockers and shower rooms for use by the opposite sex, especially children. Why would anyone in his right mind demand to throw open the doors of such facilities to all sexes and persuasions who want to come in? Has he completely lost his mind?
Homosexuals are the only people on earth who are actually sexually aroused by smelly public toilets. That is their favored pick-up spot and where they most enjoy sexual encounters.
It is remembered how in New York’s Lincoln Center, restrooms became a problem. They had become a sodomite gathering place. One time I went in and homos were going at it. One man, whose upper body and head was seen over the stop of the stall was obviously standing on the toilet, while the other gave him oral sex, accompanied by “OOOOH” and AHHHHH.” Sickening!
But remember, what the “gays” say, “Why we are just like everyone else.” No they are not. A feature front page story in the San Francisco Chronicle spotlighted a “gay couple,” and described the elaborate home the two men shared “In the foyer”, the writer gushed, “is a purple urinal sculpture.” What?
Now read that carefully. Why on earth would any functioning human being have such a thing in the foyer of their house to greet guests? And yes, they do try to pick up little boys in the public restrooms. This is documented fact.
A pastor I knew was a bear of a man with great strength. He walked into a ‘men’s room and came upon a helpless little boy with his pants pulled down and a sodomite kneeling next to him ready to complete the assault and rape. This pastor charged in, grabbed the pervert, beat him to a bloody pulp, and took the little boy outside to find his parents.
Now back to Bruce Springsteen. So what do his fans have to do with a legal action taken by the state? Nothing! They, the fans, are the ones Springsteen is punishing, disappointing them by cancelling that concert suddenly. Springsteen is also punishing himself by willfully losing the revenue of his scheduled concert and basically beginning his road to oblivion. All because of his own demented mind set.
The LGBTQ “community” consists of a strange sect who live on the outskirts (or- out IN skirts) draping over the edge of society and who defy all social norms. They demand that the world not only fully accept their aberrant lifestyle but to participate in it. Or else!
So why is this rocker so insistent that all restroom doors must be flung open to allow anyone full access to a facility for the opposite sex? And how does he refer to these degenerates in his interviews? Brace yourselves: He publicly calls them, ‘freedom fighters.’ Yes, fighters for the freedom to advance perversion of all kinds. This makes one wonder what Springsteen is hiding in HIS closet.
This latest flagrant violation of privacy must be stopped. The State of North Carolina is absolutely correct. Yet Springsteen is so determined to provide young flesh for sexual deviants, that he thinks he is punishing North Carolina by cancelling a concert there.
First of all, where is the old Show Business Anthem, “The Show Must Go On?” In another era long ago. we had REAL entertainers who had moral values, never used vulgar language and did their shows no matter what happened in their lives. What’s more, they had talent. I remember the story of Eddie Cantor who received news of his mother’s sudden death just as he was about to go on stage.
Cantor did his show, gave it all he had, then came off stage and collapsed in his dressing room in grief. Our older generation did it right. The whole idea of entertainment was to transport the audience pleasantly away from the growing disturbing issues in the world and into a place of joy.
Entertainers were a welcome stabilizing influence on the public and were honorable in character. Show business itself was an honorable profession. Not today. It promotes all the wrong things with no redeeming factor whatsoever. Today,it is a useless waste of time. Especially when you have an aging rock star pushing his seventies, who is about over the hill, trying to be significant and going to every disgusting length to attain it. And this includes furthering immorality and shameful sexual practices and abuse.
He let down his loyal fans, 15,000 of them, who had paid $25-$100 a ticket to see and hear him. It was a struggle for many of them to get together the price for the ticket. It is certain none of them will ever buy a ticket to see and hear this misfit again. Nor should anyone else. He seems to forget that it was his fans that put him over the top .Plus he has broken a proud tradition of real show business, which he probably never had in the first place.
Bruce Springsteen is a disgrace to show business, a disgrace to his fans, a disgrace to humanity and a disgrace to himself. He has chosen to exit an otherwise successful career in disgrace, since he will never have a fan base again. Why should anyone ever want to see or hear him again? All due to stupidity.
Veteran DJ Lewis in Wisconsin claims he was 5 feet away from RNC chairman Reince Priebus when he overheard that the GOP’s voting machine had been purposely rigged to keep Donald Trump under 50 percent. Lewis said he recorded the chairman’s conversation, but the mainstream media is refusing to run the story. “Already have tried 8 different places. I even taped his conversation and they tell me that is illegal,” wrote Lewis.
Lewis said he warned others that the voting machines in Wisconsin would be rigged.
After hearing the combat veteran talking privately about the Gospel to his friends, the mall cop interrupts them and says that they aren’t allowed to discuss religion on private property.
He then threatens to charge them with criminal trespassing if they don’t leave.